The Brutal Telling

The Brutal Telling

[an Inspector Gamache Crime Novel]

Book - 2009
Average Rating:
Rate this:
A stranger is found murdered in the village bistro and antiques store and all clues point to bistro owner Olivier being the killer. Once again, Chief Inspector Gamache and his team are called in to strip back layers of lies, exposing both treasures and rancid secrets long buried--but not forgotten.
Publisher: London : Headline, 2009.
ISBN: 9780755341030
Characteristics: viii, 374 p. ; 24 cm.


From the critics

Community Activity


Add a Comment
Feb 09, 2021


Sep 26, 2020


Mar 30, 2020

THE BRUTAL TELLING is the fifth installment of author Louise Penny’s popular mystery series. The inimitable Inspector Armand Gamache returns to the remote Quebec village of Three Pines to solve yet another murder. As the story unfolds, he and his team interact with the many quirky residents of Three Pines that fans like me have grown to love, along with a few new ones. But all is not light-hearted. The characters, who charmed readers in previous books, now are slowly revealing their flaws and imperfections. This is the darkest book so far in the series. The setting of the dense woods and forest is so integral to the story’s mood and plot. Secrets and lies abound. Author Louise Penny does a masterful job balancing the tragic with moments of humor while including a little Canadian history and First Nations culture. At the end of this complex puzzle, readers are left to ponder the fate of one of Three Pines’ locals. I’m looking forward to Book #6.

JCLS_Ashland_Kristin Feb 19, 2020

I struggle with sticking with cozy mystery series...and while these are only MOSTLY cozy, I occasionally have a hard time suspending my disbelief at the number of murders in this small town setting. However, I really do enjoy the characters and keep reading!

Oct 31, 2019

Second in Armand Gamache mysteries set in Montreal (have read the first, Still Life 11/16)

Apr 13, 2019

The best story in the series (so far). Much to ponder in relation to the storyline.

Apr 04, 2018

Not Penny's best work. The final chapter seems like a coda wherein the author tries to convince the reader of the plot conclusion. I found myself as much in disbelief as one of the main characters.

Dec 20, 2017

Another great Louise Penny book. Chief Inspector Gamache books are always engrossing. Great character development helps immensely.

Jun 05, 2017

Multiple "brutal tellings" drive the characters in the fifth and, so far, best book of the series as Penny continues to develop her writing skills. The scene is shifting in Three Pines; the idyllic pastime of its denizens is perturbed as new inhabitants arrive and a beloved villager departs in shocking disgrace. What do these disquieting changes bode for the next book?!

rb3221 May 18, 2017

A story that revolves around the deep troubling secrets of one of the residents of Three Pines. Could Olivier possibly be a murderer? Greed, jealousy and fear of exposure are themes in this novel. Have the characters and lives of the Three Pines residents changed forever?
A bit of a disappointing ending and not my favorite Penny novel but still an entertaining, good read.

View All Comments


Add a Quote
Mar 30, 2020

“Gamache knew it was impossible to split language from culture. That without one the other withered. To love the language was to respect the culture.” - p. 340

Mar 30, 2020

“Funny how imperfections on the outside mean something splendid beneath.” - p. 103

Mar 30, 2020

“Murders are about emotions. Emotions gone bad and gone wild. Remember that. And don’r ever think you know what someone else is thinking, never mind feeling.” - p. 75

PimaLib_SamR Mar 07, 2016

Better to accept the wretched truth than struggle, twisting, to make a wish a reality.

Age Suitability

Add Age Suitability

There are no age suitabilities for this title yet.


Add a Summary

There are no summaries for this title yet.


Add Notices

There are no notices for this title yet.

Explore Further

Browse by Call Number


Subject Headings


Find it at WPL

To Top